Smart Home

Employers wary of AI-written resumes but rely on AI for early hiring steps

Most employers say they have rejected candidates over AI-generated resumes, yet many use AI tools to conduct initial interviews, according to Greenhouse.

Most US employers say they have turned away real job applicants because their resumes looked fake or written by AI, according to new data from hiring software company Greenhouse. At the same time, half of these companies now use AI-powered interviews to screen candidates, the company found.

Greenhouse surveyed 1,347 hiring managers and recruiters in the US, UK, Germany, Australia and Ireland in late September and early October. The findings point to rising suspicion about AI's influence on job applications, yet a growing dependence on the same technology in the hiring process.

Skepticism and new hiring tactics

Nine in ten US employers said they believed they had rejected genuine applicants because the resumes appeared fake or generated by AI. Greenhouse clarified it did not know if employers used AI detection tools or were going by instinct, since the survey relied on self-reported impressions rather than hard evidence.

Ophir Samson, Head of Voice AI at Greenhouse, told ZDNET by email that the numbers reflect what employers believe, not what has been measured. “The survey data is self-reported, so it reflects what employers believe has happened, not a measured outcome,” Samson said.

The report shows that 86% of companies have made changes to their hiring process to address AI’s impact. The most common adjustment is to add another round of human interviews, with 57% saying they increased human involvement.

As job seekers turn to AI tools to improve their resumes and cover letters, employers find it harder to judge who fits their roles, Greenhouse’s report said. Automated resume screeners can weed out most applications, so many candidates adjust their materials to beat the bots, sometimes making themselves look less authentic in the process.

AI tools for screening and interviews

Even as suspicion grows, AI continues to play a larger role in hiring. Half of the employers surveyed said they now use AI-based interviews, mainly voice technology, to reach more candidates at the earliest stages. Of those using voice AI interviews, 40% said the technology helped them discover strong candidates they would have missed.

Greenhouse markets its own AI-powered voice interview tool. Samson described a case where an HR professional ran 200 previously rejected candidates through the tool. The AI suggested 19 for another look. All five of the finalists, and the person ultimately hired, came from this group, Samson said.

Samson insisted that the tool does not make final decisions. “Recruiters review every output, and one recruiter owns the outcome and can explain how they reached it,” he said. Greenhouse’s Voice AI does not automatically advance or reject anyone, according to him.

Greenhouse found that employers are still wary of letting AI make the final call. Only 7% said they would let AI agents decide which applicants should advance. Most prefer to keep humans in charge of the most important hiring steps.

AI interviews and job seekers’ experience

While employers bring in more technology, applicants are not always put off. In a previous Greenhouse survey, only 7% of US job seekers said they would refuse an AI interview. Among those who completed one, 70% reported it helped them show their abilities.

Samson said the tough job market could be making applicants more open to AI, but he cautioned against assuming it is just desperation. “Candidates are setting clear conditions: nearly half want to know if a human will review their responses and 40% want to know how they’ll be evaluated,” he said.

One example involved Ryan Quinlan, a software engineer who landed a job at Blissway after an AI interview. “Talking to an AI sounded strange to him at first,” Samson said, but Quinlan said the process allowed him to mention skills he had left out of his resume. Samson added, “For most applicants, a human conversation was never on the table. The real choice is a resume lost in a pile, or 15 minutes to tell their story.”

Greenhouse’s research also found that 81% of job seekers were rejected from a position in the past year without talking to a person, human or AI. When the hiring process does use AI, about 90% of candidates rate the experience as excellent, according to Greenhouse.

Some US states are writing laws to keep a person in the loop. A recent California law requires a human to co-sign if an AI system recommends firing an employee.

Samson said that when AI interviews are set up clearly and fairly, they benefit both sides. Greenhouse allows candidates to opt out of its AI interview process.

Greenhouse reported that when employers save time with AI hiring tools, 85% put those hours into spending more time with shortlisted candidates or interviewing more people early.

Tag: Smart Home